In a Rolling Stone magazine review called “Watch Eric Paslay’s Reflective ‘She Don’t Love You’ Video,” writer Andrew Leahey noted “Clip was filmed in a 150-year-old opera house in southern Tennessee,” referring to “She Don’t Love You.”
“Director Wes Edwards keeps things classy in the song’s newly-released music video, too,” Leahey said. “Shot inside the Staar Theater, a 150-year old opera house located on the town square of Pulaski, Tennessee, the clip switches between performance shots of Paslay and footage of his onscreen girlfriend, who twirls beneath the theater’s dismantled ceilings and peeling plaster walls in a lonely, slow-motion dance.”